Olive Oil Challah Wreath (of sorts)
Dinner party: mint-crusted lamb chops, tarragon chicken, wreath challah. To those without approaching seasonal depression, happy fall!
Oct 31, 2025
Almost like clockwork, the fall equinox happened last week and suddenly I have to film in the dark. Now nobody wants to eat on the rooftop. The air conditioning feels a little too cold. I am constantly craving apples. No longer do people come into my apartment hot and sweaty from the subway.
Don’t expect my dinner parties from this point until April to look like sun-light, golden hour little heaven scenes. We’re going for moody and lamp-lit. Try to hear the jazz noir playing in the background. I’ll do my best to not catch myself on fire with the candles burning all around my kitchen (unlikely).
If you don’t celebrate, Rosh Hashanah was last week. The Jewish new year. When we cast away the past and set ourselves up for a refreshing, exciting, and luck-filled next year. I’ll spare you the religious aspect and just focus on the food (isn’t that why we’re here?). You’re supposed to eat sweet things for the new year, hence apples dunked in honey, apple cake for dessert, brisket braised in a slightly sweet broth (most likely from coke and Heinz chili sauce…idk don’t ask me).
As you all can probably assume, I love sweet things. Rosh Hashanah dinner should be my jam (pun intended). Maybe this year I’m feeling cynical, or my sweet tooth deactivated recently, but I didn’t feel like making a dessert with dinner. Sue me! Having apples and honey at the dinner table felt sweet enough. And dunking a massive amount of homemade challah into the honey as well felt doubly sweet enough. So this is what the menu ended up looking like:
- Mint-encrusted lamb chops with pomegranate molasses drizzle
- Tarragon roast chicken breasts
- A challah wreath, or possibly a shofar, or possibly a croissaint
- Apples and honey (but I infused the honey with rosemary and Aleppo pepper)
- Radicchio salad with roast squash, fennel, and apple
- Steamed broccoli with butter
You can see how the sweetness pops up in bits and pieces but doesn’t overwhelm the menu. Much more palatable in my opinion. Like a sweet new year that doesn’t hit you over the head, one where you have to find the sweetness buried underneath the surface. A coffee with one packet of sugar, not four.
And a special note on the challah. I actually wanted it to be a ring. Rosh Hashanah challahs are supposed to be a circular loaf, but I find this form doesn’t give the dough enough room to proof and expand, resulting in denser bread. Personally, I don’t want my new year bread to be dense. So I thought a ring or wreath could be a good work around. Then I could fill the center with sliced apples as a center-piece decoration of sorts. Unfortunately, I made the crucial mistake of opting for a 6-stranded braid and didn’t have enough length to fully make a circle, which is how we ended up with a croissaint-shaped loaf (still round enough if you ask me). If you want to make an actual challah wreath, I would divide the dough just into thirds and do a normal braid, which you can loop back onto itself and bake as a circle.
Happy new year (to some) and happy fall to all,
Ryan

Hey! My name is Ryan Nordheimer. Welcome to my cooking and baking site. I’m a 25-year old home cook living in the East Village in New York City. Hopefully you enjoy my food through my own, tried-and-true recipes.
Ingredients (9)
Ingredients (9)
Instructions
To the bowl of stand mixer, add the flour (8 ¼ cups), sugar (½ cup), olive oil (½ cup), salt (2 Tbsp), yeast (2 ¼ tsp), and eggs (4). Mix on low to combine.
Increase speed to medium-low and knead for 8-10 minutes, or until the dough is smooth.
Transfer dough to a large greased bowl and cover with plastic wrap. Let proof overnight in the fridge (this will make it easier to work with, too).
The next day, press down on the dough to de-gas it.
For a 6-braid: Then remove it from the bowl and divide into 6 even pieces (around 310-320g each).
Take each piece and roll into a long log, about 24 inches but it doesn’t have to be exact. Repeat with all the pieces.
Align the 6 logs so they are vertical. Pinch them all at the top well. Then separate them so they look like an octopus somewhat.
Take the dough strand on the farthest right and move it over 2 strands. Take the second strand from the left and move it over to the far right. Take the farthest left strand and move it over 2 strands. Take the second strand from the right and move it to the far left.
Repeat this process 2-3 more times until you’ve worked your way down the braid.
Roll the two ends back and forth to seal the braids, then tuck those ends under.
Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Life up the loaf and confidently transfer it like a baby to the baking sheet. You can bend it inward slightly to create the crescent shape.
Take your herb sprigs and stick them into the crescent in varying spots, all facing the same direction, to create the wreath look.
Cover with plastic wrap or a lightly wetted tea towel and let rise in a warm spot for 1.5 hours, or until the dough has doubled in size.
Preheat the oven to 350°F.
Combine the egg yolk and heavy cream (1) in a small bowl with a fork.
Brush all over the challah. Sprinkle the challah with flaky salt.
Bake the loaf until deeply golden, well-risen, and a thermometer registers 190°F or a toothpick comes out clean, about 45 minutes.
Let cool to room temperature.



