Creme Fraiche Chicken Pot Pie

Holiday Recipes for Cozy Nights

18 ingredientsPrep: 30 minsCook: 1 hr 5 mins
Recipe image

Create an account in order to save recipes from Ryan Nordheimer

Your account will work across all sites built on Recipe.Site

Dec 11, 2025

I think we can all agree that the past 2 weeks have been a complete blur. Of food, of people, of traveling. I don’t know about you, but personally in this period of time I’ve made: shortribs, turkey, so many mashed potatoes, giant baked alaska, mini baked alaskas, twin beef wellingtons, bone-in rib-eyes, lobster rolls, 4 dozen milk bread buns, and more. Literally sounds like what you would get if you prompted ChatGPT “please write out the most absurd string of recipes you can fathom someone making in a two week period”. (After writing this sentence, I actually did ask ChatGPT that exact prompt because I was curious. It came up with “Beige Soup”, “Carbonated Meatballs”, “Burrito-Stuffed Hotdog-Stuffed Burrito”, “Fifth-Dimensional Casserole”, among many other things. Sadly, nothing I made).

So while I’m glad this period of cooking in my life is officially over. It’s nice in hindsight to reflect on it more romantically and vividly in mind, specifically by writing it into an optimistic newsletter. So here are three highlights from the end of November, recipes and moments that stand out among the rest.

To start, a creme fraiche chicken pot pie. I’m so fortunate that I got to partner with one of my favorite brands of all time Le Creuset to bring this recipe to life. I used their Signature 3.5 Quart Round Braiser as my searing and baking vessel. There’s something strangely therapeutic about searing chicken in enameled cast iron. The chicken skin becoming so deeply golden is an endorphin rush (to me, at least). And more is more when it comes to chicken pot pie. I included leeks, mushrooms, potato, parsnip, and peas, but feel free to use whatever you have on hand. And since I’m working with Le Creuset, I took the pot pie in a French direction, adding vermouth, creme fraiche, tarragon, and Dijon to the filling. I double-down on creme fraiche by using it as a healthy garnish too. The cooling, rich creme fraiche pairs beautifully with rich pastry and chicken legs.

Next are the caramelized shallot mashed potatoes I made with my friend Emerald (@emeraldcchan) for our iconic and viral creator friendsgiving. The mashed potatoes were by far the stand-out star (of the savory course; I’m not neglecting my baked alaska). They somehow stayed absolutely creamy for hours. And everyone was begging Emerald for the recipe, which I’m so dutifully publishing now.

And finally, the baked alaska. This recipe… let me tell you I was so nervous. Turns out my freezer wasn’t completely sealed, so the temperature wasn’t even the correct level of cold. I had the brilliant idea of assembling the baked alaska in my apartment, then ubering with it to Emerald’s apartment in Brooklyn. I kept poking the ice cream in my freezer thinking somehow I had messed up store-bought ice cream… I cast my doubt aside and had a very-much-fear-inducing uber ride over the Williamsburg bridge. Thankfully and somehow, the dessert went off without a hitch. It completely hardened back up in Emerald’s freezer. And then after dinner I made the meringue, coated the alaska, torched it, and then flambeed it. Iconic. One of the most memorable moments of my cooking career thus far. And it was so satisfying: getting to eat a fat slice of cold ice cream after such an over-stimulating and warm thanksgiving feast. The recipe for my baked alaska is sort of an amalgamation of several recipes. I used Isabelle Heikens’s baked alaska recipe for the most part, but swapped the ice creams for 3 pints of pistachio chip and 3 pints of cherry chip. I also increased the amount of meringue.

For the love of holiday cooking and Le Creuset,

Ryan

Ingredients (18)

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 425°F. Heat a 3.5 qt braiser over medium-high heat. Heat a 3.5 qt Le Creuset Signature Round Braiser (mine is in shade Nuit; also a big fan of Artichaut) over medium-high heat.

  2. Pat the chicken legs (3 large) dry with paper towels, then season with salt and pepper.

  3. Add olive oil (1 Tbsp) to the pan and sear the chicken legs on each side until golden, about 4-5 minutes per side.

  4. Transfer the chicken legs to a baking sheet and continue to bake in the oven until they are cooked through, another 20 - 30 minutes.

  5. Let cool.

  6. Meanwhile, to the braiser, add chopped leek (1), diced parsnip (1), diced potato (1), and sliced mushrooms (1 cup). Season with salt and pepper. Continue to cook until the vegetables have softened, about 8 - 10 minutes.

  7. Add chopped tarragon (2 Tbsp) and vermouth (½ cup). Let the alcohol cook off.

  8. Add all-purpose flour (½ cup). Cook out for 1-2 minutes.

  9. Slowly stir in chicken stock (3 cups), creme fraiche (¼ cup), and Dijon mustard (2 Tbsp).

  10. Bring to a simmer and allow the flour to thicken the sauce. Then move off heat and season with salt and pepper to taste.

  11. Add in frozen peas (1 cup).

  12. Shred the chicken with two forks. Then add to the pie filling along with any juices on the sheet tray. Discard the bones.

  13. Roll out the pie dough (1 disc) into a large rectangle. Use a pizza cutter or a long knife to cut 8 or 10 1” thick strips of pie dough.

  14. Form a lattice on top of the cooled down pot pie filling.

  15. Brush the dough with egg (1 large), sprinkle with salt and pepper, and bake until the pie dough is golden brown, about 30 minutes.

  16. Serve with additional creme fraiche (¼ cup) and chopped chives.

Comments